Our Menu
Our Flavors

Today's Flavors

We like to keep it fresh, so our flavors rotate daily! Choose a location to see today’s offerings.
Pelandale Avenue

LOW FAT
Heavenly Vanilla
Chocolate Vanilla Swirl
Darn Good Chocolate
Cookies ‘N Cream
Funfetti Cookie
Fruity Pebbles
Chocolate Covered Pretzel
Salted Caramel Pretzel
Rootbeer Float

DAIRY FREE
Jacob’s Blue Raspberry

  • NON FAT
    Double Cheesecake
    Original Tart
    Blue Raspberry Tart

    NO SUGAR ADDED
    Chocolate Mousse

  • Cup Sizes

    53 cents per oz!

    Outrageous Cones

    Our custom crafted creations!
    • Magic Drumstick

      Vanilla froyo cone covered with homemade magic shell and topped with roasted peanut and almonds

    • Unicorn Cone

      Vanilla froyo cone with homemade funfetti cookie dough, white chocolate sauce, unicorn sprinkles and a unicorn pop

    • Nutter Butter Smash

      Vanilla froyo cone drizzled with Nutter Butter and non-dairy fudge sauce topped with Reese’s peanut butter cup and 2 Nutter Butter cookies

    Our Toppings

    We’re always keeping it fresh! Toppings may change regularly.
    3 scoops = 1 topping
    Specialty

    Roasted Almonds
    Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
    Funfetti Cookie Dough
    Chocolate Coma Cookie Dough
    Golden Oreo Cookie Dough
    Gluten-Free Coconut Granola
    Homemade Graham Cracker Crust
    Homemade dairy free fudge sauce
    Brownie Crumble
    Homemade Magic Shell
    Nutella
    Peanut Butter Sauce
    Honey
    Coffee Dirt
    Fresh Raspberries
    Fresh Blueberries
    Fresh Mango
    Fresh Pineapple

    Classics

    Animal Cookies
    Bananas
    Caramel Turtles
    Carob Chips
    Cheesecake Bites
    Cherries
    Chocolate Sprinkles
    Dark Chocolate Chips
    Granola
    Gummi Bears
    Heath Bar
    Hershey’s Chocolate
    Kiwi
    M&Ms
    Mango Boba
    Mochi

    Marshmallow Sauce
    Nutter Butter Sauce
    Oreos
    Peanuts
    Rainbow Sprinkles
    Reese’s Cup
    Sour Worms
    Strawberries
    Strawberry Boba
    Thin Mint Cookies
    Toasted Coconut
    Yogurt Chips
    Whipped Cream

    Shakes

    Extreme

    Chocolate Cake Extreme Shake
    Vanilla froyo, a piece of homemade chocolate cake,topped with whipped cream & dairy free chocolate sauce.

    Carrot Cake Shake
    Vanilla froyo, a piece of homemade carrot cake,topped with whipped cream &white chocolate shavings.

    Classics

    Oreo
    Reese’s Cup
    Strawberry
    Vanilla

    Awake Shakes

    Cappuccino
    Caramel
    Mocha

    Acai Bowls

    • Rainbow

      Sambazon Acai, gluten free granola, kiwis, bananas, strawberries and blueberries.

    • Cali Protein

      Sambazon Acai, gluten free granola, strawberries, bananas, and organic peanut butter.

    • Honey Bee

      Sambazon Acai, gluten free coconut granola, blueberries, bananas and honey.

    MORE GOOD STUFF

    Smoothies

    Now Made with Original Tart!
    Strawberry Fields
    Berry Good
    Aloha Orange
    Add protein powder +1.00

    Cups

    Unicorn Cup
    Magic Drumstick Cup
    Nutterbutter Smash Cup
    Banana Split
    Strawberry Cheesecake
    Brownies N Fudge
    Fruit Parfait

    Chillers

    Our dairy free sorbet of the day blended to refreshing perfection!

    Floats & More

    Rootbeer/Pepsi Float
    Cold Brew Float
    Froyo Quarts To Go

    Cones

    3 Swirl
    6 Swirl
    Waffle cone +$2.00

    Pup-Yo!

    We couldn't forget our four-legged fur babies! Certified pet safe by a veterinarian, our Pup-Yo is our non-dairy vanilla served with a crunchy dog bone.

    Did you know that .50 cents from every Pup-Yo sold is donated back to one of our local animal shelters? We choose a different shelter every quarter to spread the much needed love for the animals in our community!

    Learn More

    Allergen Alert
    Your health is of the utmost concern to us. Please be aware that Yogurt Mill products are prepared and manufactured in an environment where allergens are present (peanuts, tree nuts, soy, wheat, milk, eggs, bee pollen or gluten). For this reason, we cannot guarantee the products being served are free of any food allergens.